A comparison of “Apples to Apples” style games: Pros and Cons

Over the course of the last couple of years I have ran into a lot of what I refer to as “Apples to Apples” clones.  These are games that all have the same basic guiding mechanic.  Players choose something and pass it to the “leader” who then picks the one that they like best and the person who submitted that thing gets a point.  First person to a certain number of points wins.  It’s a very basic concept, there are no right or wrong answers in this style of game, it just a matter of playing to your judge.  Knowing them well enough to choose an option that you think will be irresistible to them.  Over the course of the last few years, I ran into many of these games, each with slightly different skews on this mechanic.

Apples to Apples is the original.  I found this game when I was working at “Games By James”  in 2005.   It was one of our biggest sellers, and it was a game I had to explain roughly 500 times a day, more over the Christmas season.

Some of the cards available in Apples to Apples.

Apples to Apples has two different types of cards:  green cards which are adjectives, and red cards which are nouns.   The leader picks a green card from the box and reads it out loud.  For example “Fluffy” might be a chosen adjective.  Then each player looks at their hand of red cards and tries to pick a noun that they think will be chosen by the leader.  Some times these rounds are very literal, such as “Bunny” would be a very literal interpretation of “Fluffy”.  However, that doesn’t necessarily make it the winner.  Often in this game, the winner is the player who can cause the biggest laugh, or otherwise strikes a more personal chord with the judge.

Because of this, I always found Apples to Apples to be very limiting in it’s enjoyment by players.  Maybe one choice every round will result in a laugh, sometimes less then that.  Other times the choices are made based upon inside jokes which will only be understood by the submitter and the judge, leaving others in the dark.  So while this is the original for this genre, it is far from my favorite adaptation.

Some time later I was introduced to “The T-Shirt Game“.  This game seemed to solve my most basic issue with the original Apples to Apples.  This game brought forth laughter for all involved, rather then relying on esoteric or inside jokes.  This game worked upon the premise of matching a t-shirt design with a funny caption.  This was geared for hilarity in it’s creation.

The T-shirt game however, did not hold to the model of “1 point” per chosen card.  Instead, players received a card off of the prize deck for each round that they won.  These cards could be worth a lot of points, or just a few points.  Because of this, sometimes games went on for far too long.  However, on the whole these cards seemed pretty balanced resulting in the person who won the most rounds still be the ultimate winner.

A round of the t-shirt game.  The t-shirt shaped card on the left has an image of a t-shirt, and is the primer card for the round.  The other cards are submitted by players to the judge as possible t-shirt captions.

A round of the t-shirt game. The t-shirt shaped card on the left has an image of a t-shirt, and is the primer card for the round. The other cards are submitted by players to the judge as possible t-shirt captions.

As if expanding on the popularity of these games, two more such games have come to my awareness in the past year:  Crappy Birthday and Faux-Cabulary.

In Crappy Birthday players pass a single card to the player who is the judge, just like in Apples to Apples and The T-shirt game.  However, the judge does not read a primer card (a card that sets up the round, like the adjective cards).  Instead players are pandering directly to their judge, trying to choose from their hand the birthday present that the judge will hate the most.  While the premise was funny, the replay-ability of this game was almost null.  Approximately 200 cards came in the box, but this simply wasn’t enough to keep it fresh and interesting.

Faux-Cabulary ran into similar problems as Crappy Birthday, but it wasn’t due to the lack of a primer card.  Faux-Cabulary did something very unique, they got rid of the cards, and instead used cubes and covers to pass words created from fragments to the judge.  The word they created was based upon a silly definition read from a primer card.  For example, the primer card might read “A word for old hair gel” and the a player could create a word such as “no-frizz-tastic”.   The downfall was in the number of cubes.  Because the designer shyed away from cards for this more inventive cube style, they also limited themselves on the word possibilities.  The game only came with 21 cubes, and so only had a possibility of 126 different word fragments.  This made the game feel stale in a hurry.

A round of Faux-Cabulary in progress.

A round of Faux-Cabulary in progress.

While I am sure there are other games of this style I am missing, these are the few that seem to most closely duplicate the Apples to Apples archetype.  Other games exist on the market that have elements of Apples to Apples, but these games expand on the concept nicely, and therefore I don’t feel they should be lumped into this generic category.  Dixit is a great example of this, and is worth taking a look at.

But in this battle for the best Apples to Apples clone, for me and my group, I feel that the T-shirt game wins hands down.  It’s funnier then Apples to Apples, and it also exhibits great replay-ability, something that was desperately lacking in the other two.

This entry was posted by The_Null_Entry on Monday, September 19th, 2011 at 7:43 am and is filed under Board Game Reviews, Party Games . You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.

61 Comments

  1. We certainly have exotic hotels which have beautiful locations and awesome views come
    to these luxurious hotels to have the holiday you are most
    looking forward to you will have an amazing time
    the time of your life is waiting for you and you must grab this
    opportunity of spending time in great luxury and grand comfort the services are the best and the rooms
    are such that you will feel like a royal most important girls
    are here that you can enjoy your life at the best hotels you can ever see you will
    truly cherish the time you will spend here we will welcome you to the most glorious hotels
    you can relax in the swimming pool which must be very big and the architecture of the hotel will leave you breathless you!!

  2. I get pleasure from looking at your site. It was Really fascinating. 🙂

  3. Hola! I’ve been following your web site for
    some time now and finally got the bravery to go ahead and give you a
    shout out from Lubbock Tx! Just wanted to mention keep up the great work!

  4. Mahi says:

    Hello, i believe that i saw you visited my site so i came to go back the choose?.I’m attempting to to find issues to improve my site!I assume its good enough to use a few of your ideas!!

  5. Aw, this was a really good post. Finding the time and actual effort to produce a top notch article… but what can I say… I hesitate
    a lot and don’t seem to get anything done.

  6. Hello there! This is kind of off topic but I need some help from an established blog.
    Is it very difficult to set up your own blog? I’m not very
    techincal but I can figure things out pretty fast.
    I’m thinking about setting up my own but I’m not
    sure where to start. Do you have any tips or suggestions?
    Many thanks

  7. Genuine says:

    Amazing issues here. I’m very glad to look your post. Thank you so much and I am looking ahead to touch you. Will you kindly drop me a e-mail?

  8. Hookers says:

    I’ll right away take hold of your rss feed as I can’t to find your email subscription link or newsletter service. Do you have any? Please allow me recognise so that I could subscribe. Thanks.

  9. You really make it seem really easy along with your presentation however I to find this topic to be really one thing that I believe I would never understand. It seems too complicated and very large for me. I’m looking forward for your subsequent post, I’ll try to get the grasp of it!

  10. Riya HIranai says:

    I will right away snatch your rss feed as I can not to find your e-mail subscription hyperlink or newsletter service. Do you’ve any? Please permit me understand in order that I could subscribe. Thanks.

  11. Nice post. I was checking constantly this weblog and
    I am impressed! Extremely useful information specially the ultimate
    part 🙂 I maintain such information a lot. I was seeking this
    certain information for a long time. Thanks and good luck.

Leave a Reply

*